What is an internal audit and how is it done? ISO audit programme, report example, closure

What is an internal audit and how do you run one? ISO internal audit programme, an internal audit report example and closing findings with evidence, step by step.

FUFerhat UğurluYazSis TeamPublished: November 16, 20268 min read
In short

An internal audit is a planned, evidence-based review in which an organisation’s own staff, or people it appoints, check whether its management system follows its own rules and the standard it applies. It works like this: a programme is prepared, criteria and scope are set, an independent auditor records the findings, the report is issued and every finding is tracked until it is closed with evidence.

In the first week of the year, management asks you for the internal audit schedule. You open last year’s file: a three-page report, checklists scattered across different folders and a few items marked “closed” with no evidence behind them. It is unclear who ran the audits, which findings were really fixed and which issues came up again. Run like this, internal auditing turns into tiring bureaucracy. Set up properly, it is one of the early warnings that show whether your management system really works. This article answers, in order: what an internal audit is, how it is done, how to prepare the programme and the report, and how to close findings.

An internal audit is a planned, recorded and evidence-based review in which an organisation’s own staff, or people it appoints, check whether its management system follows its own rules and the standard it applies (for example ISO 9001) and whether it works effectively. Unlike an external audit, the organisation starts the review itself and uses the results for its own improvement.

Why do an internal audit?

  • To check conformity: does the work done on the floor match the written procedures?
  • To check effectiveness: the rules are followed, but do they also deliver the intended result?
  • To catch repetition: does the same issue come up again in other departments or in other years?
  • To prepare for the external audit: find the gaps yourself before the certification body arrives.

How to do an internal audit, step by step

  1. Define the criteria and scope. Write down what you audit against (clause of the standard, internal procedure, contract requirement) and which process, department and period the audit covers.
  2. Appoint the auditor. Choose someone who does not own the work being audited and whose competence is on record.
  3. Announce the plan in advance. Share the date and the people to be interviewed, at least with the manager of the department concerned.
  4. Hold an opening meeting. Explain the purpose, scope and method in a few sentences.
  5. Collect evidence. Combine interviews, on-site observation and record review; keep “what people say” apart from “what you see”, and note the sample you looked at.
  6. Classify the findings. Record conformity, nonconformity, observation and opportunity for improvement separately; link every nonconformity to a criterion and to evidence.
  7. Closing meeting and report. Confirm the findings with the department manager, issue the report, assign corrective actions with an owner and a deadline, and follow them until closure.

How to prepare an internal audit programme

The programme is the calendar that shows which process will be audited, when and by whom over the year. ISO 9001 (2015 edition, clause 9.2) expects audits at planned intervals and a programme that takes into account the importance of the processes, changes affecting the organisation and the results of previous audits. In other words, a process that had problems or has just changed comes earlier in the queue than one that runs smoothly. The table below is a sample programme outline for a fictional manufacturing company. Add a criteria column to your own programme: once it is clear which clause or procedure applies, the auditor can build the checklist from that column.

Process / departmentWhy in this order?Planned periodAuditor (role)
Purchasing and supplier evaluationPrevious audit raised a findingMarchProduction quality officer
Production line and process controlsNew machine put into serviceAprilPurchasing specialist
Warehouse and shippingRecord-keeping routine changedMayQuality specialist
Human resources and trainingNo findings in previous auditSeptemberPlanning officer
Document and record controlAffects all departmentsOctoberAuditor from another site or an external auditor

Why does auditor independence matter?

Someone auditing a procedure they wrote themselves struggles to see its gaps; and if writing a finding would strain the relationship with a colleague, impartiality weakens. That is why the standard asks for objectivity and impartiality when auditors are selected. In small companies everyone knows everyone else’s work; the usual answer is cross-auditing: production audits quality, quality audits the warehouse or purchasing. If cross-auditing is not possible at all, outside support is another option.

The auditor’s job is not to find someone to blame but to show where the system lacks evidence.

Internal audit report format and report example

There is no single valid report format, but the reader must be able to answer “what was checked, what was found, what will be done”. You can use the outline below as a sample report template:

  • Header: audit number, date, audited department, auditor and accompanying people.
  • Scope and criteria: which process, which period, which clause or procedure was used.
  • Method and sample: which records, which shift, how many people were interviewed.
  • Findings: nonconformities, observations and opportunities for improvement under separate headings.
  • Evidence: a record number, photo or observation note next to each finding.
  • Summary of results: the overall state of the system within scope, in one paragraph.
  • Actions and deadlines: an owner and a date for every nonconformity.

How are audit findings classified?

Finding typeWhat does it mean?Fictional exampleNext step
ConformityCriterion met and evidence existsTraining records match the planRecorded in the report, no action needed
NonconformityCriterion not metA device past its calibration date is still in useCorrection and corrective action are opened
ObservationNot yet a nonconformity, but there is a riskForms are filled in late on the new shiftReported to the department manager and monitored
Opportunity for improvementRule met, something better is possibleThe same checklist is repeated in two separate formsSuggested; management decides whether to apply it

When is a finding really closed?

“Resolved” written in the report does not mean the finding is closed. Closure should rest on three things: the problem has been corrected, a corrective action addresses its cause, and there is evidence that this action worked. The evidence can be a signed form, an updated record, a photo or clean records from the following period. The record should also show that the person approving the closure agrees with the auditor who raised the finding, or with the person that auditor designated.

Five common internal audit mistakes

  • The audit starts without written criteria; the finding becomes the auditor’s personal opinion.
  • The checklist is copied unchanged every year; changed processes and earlier findings are not reflected in it.
  • The auditor relies only on what the process owner says and does not look for records or on-site evidence.
  • The nonconformity is only corrected; nobody asks for its cause.
  • The report is issued, but follow-up on closure is left until the next audit.

Internal audits with Excel and paper: where they are enough and where they are not

In a single-site organisation with few processes and one quality officer, a programme in Excel, reports in Word and evidence in a shared folder may be enough. The real problem starts after the audit is over:

  • The finding stays inside the report; closure needs a separate spreadsheet, and the two files drift apart over time.
  • Deadlines never reach anyone’s calendar; reminders depend on the quality officer’s memory.
  • Evidence files end up scattered across e-mail, desktops and the shared folder; months later they are hard to find.
  • That the same issue came up in three separate audits only becomes visible if someone compares the reports by hand.

How does the internal audit chain work in KurumsalPortal?

The Internal Audit Management module links the steps above into a single chain of records:

  1. Plan the audit: the audit is tied to a plan.
  2. Run the checks: the audit follows a checklist, and the results are collected in the audit record.
  3. Record the finding: findings and nonconformities are recorded against the related audit; they do not stay buried in a report.
  4. Assign an action: for each finding, a corrective action with a named owner and a deadline is opened.
  5. Close with evidence: the action is closed by attaching evidence that it was completed.

The current version of the procedures the audit relies on can sit under the same roof: Document & Policy Management keeps documents under version control, so the auditor and the audited department look at the same version. Because findings are recorded against the related audit, you can also track whether the same issue comes up again in different audits.

If you want to see the audit plan, checklist and finding follow-up in one chain, take a look at the Internal Audit Management page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an internal and an external audit?

An internal audit is carried out by the organisation itself, or by people it appoints, for its own improvement. An external audit is run by an outside party such as a customer or a certification body. An internal audit is also a way to spot gaps before the external audit.

Is an internal quality audit the same as internal auditing in the financial sense?

In the quality and ISO context, an internal audit reviews whether the management system meets its criteria. Internal auditing as a corporate function is broader and can also cover financial and operational risks. In practice many companies use the terms interchangeably; what matters is that the criteria, scope and records are clear.

Who can be an internal auditor?

The organisation sets and records the competence of its auditors against its own criteria. The general principle is that people do not audit their own work and can stay impartial. You can use ISO 19011, a widely used guideline for auditing management systems, as a reference for competence and audit management.

What happens if an internal audit finding is not closed on time?

The finding stays open and comes up again at the next audit. That is why every finding needs an owner, a deadline and closure evidence, and delays should be visible to management.

How long should an internal audit report be?

There is no fixed page count. The report is sufficient if it gives the reader the full picture of scope, criteria, findings, evidence and actions. Linking each finding to evidence and to an owner matters more than long descriptions.

FU
Ferhat Uğurlu · YazSis Team

Builds enterprise software, AI and digital transformation products together with the YazSis team.