Maintenance tracking software vs Excel: when to switch for preventive maintenance

Maintenance software or Excel? Where a spreadsheet works and where it breaks for preventive maintenance, four methods compared and criteria for switching.

FUFerhat UğurluYazSis TeamPublished: November 23, 20268 min read
In short

Preventive maintenance can be tracked in Excel; with a few machines and a single person responsible for maintenance, a spreadsheet does the job. A spreadsheet struggles with looking up history, assigning work, reminders and tracking parts and costs. If a planned maintenance task has been missed, copies of the file are circulating or maintenance knowledge depends on one person, it is time to move to maintenance tracking software.

Your maintenance plan lives in an Excel file: machines in the rows, months in the columns, colours in the cells. The person who built the file did a good job, and it served you for years. Now there are more machines, two shifts and a bigger maintenance team, and the coloured cells no longer tell you who did what. The question “Should we drop Excel and switch to maintenance tracking software?” is on the table, but the effort and risk of switching are real too. This article honestly separates where Excel is enough from where it is not, and gives you criteria for the decision.

Preventive maintenance tracking is the work of planning, assigning, reminding about and recording the maintenance that machines and equipment need at set intervals. It can be done in Excel; the real difference between a spreadsheet and software is not computing power but record-keeping discipline. At the end, we also explain how this work is split across two modules in YazSis KurumsalPortal.

When is Excel enough for preventive maintenance tracking?

  • You track only a few machines, all at the same site.
  • One person prepares and updates the maintenance plan.
  • You rarely need to look back and ask “How many times has this machine broken down?”
  • Reminders come from the person who opens the spreadsheet, and the cost of a missed maintenance task is low.
  • Parts and costs are tracked somewhere else, and that does not bother you.

If these conditions describe you, there is no rush to leave Excel. A well-built spreadsheet, with fixed columns, drop-down lists and a single copy, serves many businesses for a long time.

Five rules for using Excel with the fewest losses

  1. Use one row per machine and maintenance type; do not repeat the same machine in two places.
  2. Format date columns as real dates, not text; otherwise sorting and colour coding break.
  3. Separate the “last maintenance” and “next maintenance” columns, and let a formula calculate the next one.
  4. Do not delete history: add a new row for each maintenance task performed and keep the old ones.
  5. Keep the file in a single shared location and name only one person as the owner of the plan.

Where does maintenance tracking in Excel break down?

  • Reminders: A spreadsheet does not warn anyone on its own. If nobody opens it, delays become invisible; conditional formatting changes a colour but notifies no one.
  • Assignment: A cell colour does not tell you who has a job. Maintenance slips through the gap between “I thought it was done” and “that was their job”.
  • History: When you overwrite the maintenance date with the next date, the previous record is lost. A machine’s full history needs a separate sheet, and nobody keeps it up to date.
  • Concurrency: When two people work in the same file, conflicts, copies and the “which one is current?” debate begin.
  • Parts and costs: Parts used stay in one spreadsheet and costs stay in accounting; nobody ever sees a machine’s total maintenance cost.
  • Link to breakdowns: Unplanned breakdowns are recorded somewhere else; maintenance intervals are never updated with breakdown data.

Four methods side by side: paper, Excel, WhatsApp and maintenance software

MethodWhere does it work well?Where does it break down?
Paper logbook or formOne machine, one technician; needs no electricity or computer.Gets lost, cannot be searched, sends no reminders; compiling history requires counting by hand.
ExcelA few machines, one person responsible; easy to set up and flexible.Weak on reminders, assignment and multiple users; history and costs stay scattered.
WhatsApp groupInstant communication and photo sharing.It is not a record; messages scroll away, searching is hard and who did what becomes unclear.
Maintenance software, for example a portal moduleMany machines and several teams; plan, assignment, history and costs in one record.Takes effort to set up and to change habits; if nobody enters records, it stays empty.

The warning in the last row of the table matters: software does not bring order by itself. If the team does not enter records, even the most comprehensive program is no different from an empty spreadsheet. The success of a switch depends less on features than on record-keeping habits on the shop floor.

A fictional example: the cell that changed colour unseen

Picture a mid-sized plastic injection moulding workshop. The oil change for the cooling pump sat in a single cell of the spreadsheet as the “next maintenance” date. The person who entered the date went on leave, and the colleague covering for them did not open the spreadsheet; the cell turned red, but nobody saw it. The maintenance was a month late, the pump overheated and the line stopped for a shift. There was no error in the spreadsheet; what was missing was a mechanism that ties an upcoming job to a person and notifies them in time. This is very often exactly where Excel reaches its limit.

Seven criteria for switching from Excel to maintenance tracking software

If three or more of the following are true for you today, it is time to consider the switch seriously:

  1. A planned maintenance task was missed, and you only noticed when a breakdown happened.
  2. Several copies of the same file are circulating.
  3. Working out a machine’s total maintenance and parts cost takes hours.
  4. Maintenance jobs are spread across several technicians, and who has what is explained verbally.
  5. Only one person monitors maintenance dates, and tracking stops when that person is on leave.
  6. To say which machine breaks down often, you rely on the technician’s memory.
  7. When management asks for a report, the data is compiled by hand.

How do you move an existing Excel spreadsheet to a new system?

Do not throw the spreadsheet away; it is the most organised record of your maintenance knowledge. The move can proceed like this:

  1. Clean up the equipment list: Give each machine one code and one name; if the same machine is written two ways, merge them.
  2. Start with critical machines: Begin with the few machines whose downtime costs the most; do not try to move everything at once.
  3. Extract the maintenance plan rows: For each machine, write down which maintenance is done, how often and by whom.
  4. Prepare the last maintenance dates: You do not have to move the full history; the last maintenance date and known recurring faults are a good start.
  5. Run the spreadsheet in parallel for a while: Once records have settled in the new system, turn the old spreadsheet into a read-only archive.

The most common mistake in the move is trying to transfer every column of the spreadsheet to the new system as it is. Columns nobody looks at, half-filled notes and old machine codes pollute the new system from day one. The switch is a chance to identify the part of the spreadsheet that is actually used and archive the rest. If you cannot remember when you last used a column, you most likely do not need to move it.

The portal as a maintenance management system: maintenance plans and date reminders

In the Maintenance & Fault Management module, maintenance plans are defined, fault and maintenance jobs are assigned to technicians, and completed maintenance is recorded in the equipment history; spare parts and costs are kept in the same history. The points where the spreadsheet breaks down, namely assignment, history and parts and costs, are thus brought together in a single record.

For date-driven tracking there is the Reminder Module. It tracks inspection, permit, contract, maintenance and periodic check dates with recurrence rules and sends alerts by portal notification, e-mail and SMS 30, 7 and 1 day before a critical date. E-mail is sent through the organisation’s own SMTP account and SMS through its own NetGSM account; completion of each period is recorded. Which module you use depends on whether you are tracking maintenance that needs a technician assigned or a check where a date alert is enough; you can settle this in the needs assessment meeting.

KurumsalPortal runs on the customer’s own server and is used from a phone browser without installing an app. There is no ready-made ERP integration; if data needs to flow, this is decided together during the needs analysis. If you provide maintenance as a service to your customers rather than for your own machines, Maintenance & Service Tracking software is a better starting point for the flow of requests, work orders, technicians and spare parts.

If you have noticed where your Excel spreadsheet breaks down, coming to a needs assessment meeting with your current file makes the work easier. For the module’s scope, see the Maintenance & Fault Management page.

Frequently asked questions

Can you track maintenance in Excel?

Yes. With a few machines and one person responsible for maintenance, a spreadsheet kept with fixed columns and as a single copy does the job. As reminders, work assignment, multi-user work and parts and cost tracking grow, the spreadsheet starts to fall short.

How do you set up preventive maintenance reminders in Excel?

You can use conditional formatting to colour dates that are approaching or overdue. But Excel sends no notifications to anyone; only the person who opens the spreadsheet sees the colours. Automatic alerts require a separate reminder tool.

Which makes more sense: maintenance tracking software or Excel?

It depends on the number of machines and people. With one person responsible and a few machines, Excel is enough. If planned maintenance is being missed, history needs to be looked up and jobs are spread across several technicians, maintenance software makes more sense.

Can existing Excel data be moved to a new system?

The spreadsheet is the most valuable source for the data to be prepared for the new system: the equipment list, the maintenance plan and the last maintenance dates. How the data is transferred into KurumsalPortal is decided together during the needs analysis.

Can the Reminder Module track maintenance dates?

Yes. The Reminder Module tracks inspection, permit, contract, maintenance and periodic check dates with recurrence rules, sends alerts 30, 7 and 1 day before the date and records completed periods.

FU
Ferhat Uğurlu · YazSis Team

Builds enterprise software, AI and digital transformation products together with the YazSis team.