How to set up an employee suggestion system: kaizen approach, factory examples, 5 steps

How do you set up an employee suggestion system? The kaizen idea, suggestion examples from factories and a five-step guide from collecting ideas to feedback.

FUFerhat UğurluYazSis TeamPublished: November 18, 20268 min read
In short

A corporate suggestion system collects employees’ improvement ideas through one channel, evaluates them, assigns an owner and reports the outcome back to the person who made the suggestion. Five steps are enough to set it up: collection, evaluation, owner assignment, implementation and feedback. The most critical step is the last one; a system that never answers gradually falls out of use.

A fictional example: at a packaging plant, a line operator notices that the line stops for a while on every shift during pallet changes, and thinks of a simple layout change that would prevent it. The operator mentions it to the shift supervisor, who says “write it down”; the note gets lost somewhere. Some time later, the same idea comes up again in a meeting, this time from another operator. The idea was never missing. What was missing was a suggestion system to collect it, link it to its owner and report back on the result.

A corporate suggestion system is the process that collects employees’ improvement ideas about work, products, safety and the working environment through a single channel, evaluates them, assigns them to an owner and reports the outcome back to the person who made the suggestion. This article explains how to set up the system with a kaizen mindset, what kinds of suggestions come up in factories and how to run the process in a portal.

What is kaizen, and how does it relate to a suggestion system?

Kaizen is a concept of Japanese origin meaning small, continuous improvement. Instead of waiting for a big transformation project, it aims to make some part of the work a little better every day. A suggestion system is the infrastructure for this approach: the improvement idea is usually spotted by the person who does the job every day, and the system makes sure that idea is evaluated rather than lost. The effect of each suggestion may be small, but as many small fixes add up, the line, the warehouse and the office start working differently. What matters is that these ideas do not stay with individuals but enter the company’s recorded memory, because the improvement should stay in place even when the person who thought of it moves to another shift or another job.

Suggestion system examples in factories: what kinds of ideas come from which area?

The table below consists of general examples; it was not taken from any of our customers. Its purpose is to help you think, before setup, about which unit will evaluate what.

AreaTypical suggestionWho evaluatesHow it is implemented
Production lineA layout change that removes the waiting point during pallet changesProduction engineer and shift supervisorTested on a pilot line, then written into the work instruction
Warehouse and shippingRearranging shelf locations around fast-moving productsWarehouse managerTried in one aisle first, then rolled out
MaintenanceAdding a preventive check for a part that fails oftenMaintenance leadA new item is added to the maintenance plan
QualityA checkpoint that catches the defect at the first station instead of at the end of the lineQuality leadA step is added to the checklist
Occupational health and safetyA warning sign and guidance at a walkway with a slip riskOccupational safety specialistApplied on site and explained to every shift
AdministrationMoving paper forms to digital formsManager of the relevant unitDesigned together with the process owner
Energy and wasteSwitching off idle equipment at the end of the shiftFacilities managerAdded to the shift handover checklist

How to set up a corporate suggestion system: five steps

Set up the system as a small process, not as a project. All five steps should fit on one page, every step should have an owner, and for the first weeks you should start with just one unit, for example a single production line or a single warehouse. Letting the process settle there before rolling it out makes it easier for both managers and employees to build the habit.

Step 1 – Collection. Ideas should come in through a single door. A short suggestion form that an operator can open on their phone must be easier than telling the shift supervisor; otherwise the system will not be used. Ask only three things on the form: what is suggested, which area it concerns and the expected benefit.

Step 2 – Evaluation. Write down in advance the criteria each suggestion will be evaluated against: feasibility, expected impact, effort required and risk. Decide who reviews what by topic; maintenance suggestions go to the maintenance lead, safety suggestions to the occupational safety specialist. Set a time limit for evaluation, because a suggestion left waiting is the biggest morale killer.

Step 3 – Owner assignment. Every accepted idea needs an owner, a deadline and a status. An idea without an owner stays in the meeting minutes. Write down a reason for rejected ideas too; the difference between “not now” and “never” decides whether the employee will bring another suggestion.

Step 4 – Implementation. Start small: one line, one aisle, one shift. Record the result of the trial; if it worked, make it the standard, and if it did not, write down why. A recorded failure is also a gain, because the same idea will not be tried again.

Step 5 – Feedback. Tell the person who made the suggestion the outcome: was it accepted, when will it be implemented, why was it rejected? If possible, announce implemented ideas in a shared space. When this step is skipped, the other four lose their value; the employee concludes that the suggestion went nowhere and does not write a second one.

How do you know whether the system is working?

Once the suggestion system is in place, the first question is usually “how many suggestions came in?”, but on its own that number is misleading. Look at the health of the flow rather than the count. The following five indicators make up a short scorecard you can review every month after setup:

  • Response rate: What share of incoming suggestions received a first response?
  • Evaluation time: How long did a suggestion wait from arrival to decision?
  • Implementation rate: What share of accepted suggestions actually reached the shop floor?
  • Range of contributors: Are ideas coming from every shift and every unit, or from just a few people?
  • Recurring topics: If suggestions keep coming in for the same problem, the root cause has still not been solved.

Instead of telling employees to “write more suggestions”, these indicators show the manager where the flow is blocked. For example, if the response rate is low, the problem lies with the evaluators, not with the employees.

Why do suggestion systems quietly die?

  • Nobody responds to submitted suggestions.
  • Filling in the form is harder than saying the idea out loud.
  • There is no set evaluation time; a suggestion stays “under review” for months.
  • Accepted ideas have no owner.
  • Only a few people write suggestions; the rest do not see the system as theirs.
  • The debate about rewards gets more attention than the ideas themselves.
  • Management never announces the improvements that were implemented.

Do you need a points and reward system?

Some companies use thank-yous, recognition meetings or small rewards; others use none at all. If you introduce rewards, watch out for two risks: disputes over who really owns an idea, and a pile-up of many low-quality suggestions submitted for the sake of the reward. Get the system working first and add rewards later. The flow defined by the module is collection, classification, assignment, tracking and feedback; scoring and reward schemes sit outside this flow and are a matter for management to decide separately.

Are a suggestion box, Excel and meetings enough?

In a small workshop, starting with a box and a shared spreadsheet is reasonable. A box is easy for shy employees, but since nobody knows who wrote the note, no feedback can be given. Excel works for a small number of suggestions; as the number grows, it becomes hard to see which one is with whom and at what stage, and there are no deadline reminders. An idea mentioned verbally at an end-of-shift meeting is forgotten as soon as the meeting ends. All three approaches break down at the point where they fail to get an answer back to the person who had the idea.

How does an employee suggestion system run in KurumsalPortal?

The Suggestion / Complaint / Request Management module of YazSis KurumsalPortal offers the employee suggestion system as a five-step flow: receive the submission, classify it, assign an owner, track the resolution, give feedback. Employees submit their suggestion through the portal in a few steps; the record is classified, assigned to an owner and given a deadline, and its status shows which stage the idea has reached. Once the resolution has been followed through, the employee is notified of the outcome.

For a line operator who does not work at a computer, the practical point is that the portal can be used from a phone browser without installing an app. On the management side, the topics that receive the most feedback are analysed, which makes improvement areas visible; you read which area keeps generating suggestions straight from the records instead of counting by hand. KurumsalPortal runs on the customer’s own server.

If you have designed the five steps on paper and are ready to try the flow, take a look at the KurumsalPortal modules and think of the suggestion system under the same roof as your other processes.

Frequently asked questions

How do you set up a corporate suggestion system?

In five steps: collecting suggestions through a single channel, evaluating them against defined criteria, assigning an owner and a deadline to each accepted idea, implementing on a small scale and giving feedback to the person who made the suggestion. Define the channel and the owners first, then the criteria.

What is the difference between an employee suggestion system and a suggestion box?

A box only collects ideas. An employee suggestion system classifies each idea, assigns it to an owner, tracks its status and deadline and reports the outcome back to the person who made the suggestion.

Are kaizen and a suggestion system the same thing?

No. Kaizen is an approach of small, continuous improvement. A suggestion system is one of the tools that puts this approach into practice: it organises how improvement ideas are collected and implemented.

Does a suggestion system need rewards?

No. Rewards are not a necessary part of a working system. Collection, evaluation and feedback must work properly first; if wanted, a reward scheme can be added later with clear rules.

How does a suggestion system work in a factory with shifts?

Suggestions should be easy to submit from a phone with a short form, and evaluation and feedback times should be planned around the shift pattern. If accepted ideas are written into the shift handover notes, the result reaches every shift.

FU
Ferhat Uğurlu · YazSis Team

Builds enterprise software, AI and digital transformation products together with the YazSis team.